Skip to main content
Back to Blog
Safety Systems

How does a digital PTW operate and what are the key considerations?

November 202614 min read
Site team reviewing a digital permit to work

Once implemented, a digital permit-to-work (PTW) will see the process of securing and undertaking dangerous operations conducted electronically. From initial request through hazard identification, isolation, sign-off, transfer and completion, a series of discrete activities will take place. Each will generate an audit trail showing who performed the activity and the date. Once the PTW is linked to the actual plant/site status, such as isolations, test results, plant operating status and workforce, there is significant value. However, simply digitising a permit will not achieve this.

In the following we look at the typical flow of a digital PTW, the minimum requirements set by US OSHA, factors to consider when evaluating an electronic solution and linking to existing assets.

Connect Permits to Site Systems

PODTECH provides bespoke Enterprise Solutions and has extensive experience working with BMS and PMS platforms to deliver these types of solutions for key assets.

Visit

TL;DR

  • Permit to work (PTW) is a documented procedure to manage the undertaking of hazardous activities and inform the site, supervisory and operational teams of permitted works and associated prerequisites.
  • To be effective, an electronic PTW must control the procedure and ensure appropriate levels of delegation, completion of pre-requisites, verifiable sign-offs and closure.
  • Under US OSHA regulation 29 CFR 1910.146, certain Confined Spaces require the issue of a permit and associated records to be retained for a minimum period. Specifically, revoked permits must be stored for 1 year for the purpose of the annual assessment.
  • By integrating the PTW with other building, telemetry and asset platforms, the live status of the facility can be incorporated.
  • PODTECH develops bespoke Enterprise Solutions and has experience of interfacing with BMS and PMS to implement this.

Table of Contents

What a digital permit to work is

The HSE defines a PTW in its publication HSG250 here. It should encompass a formal, documented process to control hazardous work and act as a communication channel between the various levels of responsibility at a given site. Importantly, a PTW is therefore comprised of more than just a form. There should be a known roster of individuals empowered to raise and approve PTWs, along with competency requirements to undertake and monitor the PTW and associated activities. Furthermore, a method of describing the works to be undertaken, applicable risk assessments, expected timescale and mitigations will need to be established.

An electronic or digital PTW will replicate these principles, facilitated via a software platform. Whether the PTW is initiated from mobile device or PC, the flow of the activity will be governed by the configuration of the system, and the resultant PTW will capture the relevant information and scope of authorisation. As noted above, however, there is no inherent assurance that hazards have been removed or otherwise adequately controlled.

This could span a range of activities such as hot works, confined space, working aloft, isolating and LOTO, pitting, lifting and removing isolation points from process lines. Within a datacentre, examples would include working on energised electrical and chilled water circuits, and in proximity to submerged IT assets. Further detail can be found in our blog on Health and Safety in Data Centres.

The permit to work process, step by step

As highlighted, there will be similarities with a traditional, paper-based PTW. The key difference is the ability to impose constraints to prevent the next stage being progressed. The process described is taken from a publicly available document outlining a comprehensive scheme used by a major company, Suncor.

1. Define works to be undertaken

The person wishing to undertake the activity will specify the relevant details, for example description, site, asset(s), period and personnel. Failure to define the scope appropriately is likely to result in the subsequent hazards and controls not being identified. Electronic solutions should therefore seek to enforce a degree of rigour and consistency, so that multiple PTWs of a comparable nature appear similar. It should not be possible to lift a prior example and reuse as is, which the HSE expressly advises against see above.

2. Identify and mitigate associated hazards

Depending on the activity, a suitable level of risk assessment should be completed. Per Suncor's approach, if the activity is considered cold then a reduced assessment will suffice. If the operation involves an ignition source in a Hazardous Area, removal of containment, confined space, critical work or any unusual high-risk scenario, a detailed sequential evaluation is required. Relevant pre-requisite actions will then be attributed to an individual or team and completed.

3. Establish and verify isolations

It's at this stage that the benefits of moving to digital become clear. Suncor's solution will require a baseline gas reading to be obtained to allow a hot work permit to progress if working in a Hazardous Area, to breach containment from a hydrocarbon installation, or for entry into a Confined Space. A Hazard Assessment, Certificate of Group Isolation(s) and relevant checklists will also be needed. The Permit will not be live until all of the above have been satisfied. On a paper Permit, this would rely on a user observing an empty field.

Requestscope, asset, teamHazardsRA + controlsIsolationsgas, LOTO, checksApprovalsign-off + issueWorksuspend / handoverArchive + audit trailstophard stops block progress

4. Approval and issue

As discussed above, there are a number of key individuals involved. Each will be required to sign off certain conditions to allow the Permit to progress through the system. The Approver will verify that all pre-requisites are met, the asset(s) isolated and zero energy declared, and that appropriate safe systems of work are applied within their jurisdiction. Of course, your Permit process will vary and you will have different titles, but it is critical that the system enforces these actions being signed off by the relevant individual(s).

Additionally, as per the HSE publication: Permits should not be issued from a distance without site attendance, and once live a Permit should not be amended unless all parties are aware.

5. Work, suspension and handover

There will be many reasons why a Permit needs to be suspended, such as adverse weather conditions, change of shift, other concurrent works and so on. The system should therefore allow a Permit to be suspended, transferred between shifts and concurrent works managed, to reduce the risk of conflicting activities. There will be a formal transfer of information to the next party accepting the Permit, which is recorded in the system.

6. Close-out and archive

Once the activity has ceased and the Permitting Area rendered safe, the Permit can be closed out by the Permit Authoriser and the data retained. As noted earlier, the HSE recommends that Permits be held on-site for a minimum of 30 days from cessation and subsequently retained. For US sites, the period of retention will depend on the type of Permit, as outlined below.

Requirements imposed by US OSHA

Although there is no generic OSHA regulation explicitly prescribing the requirements of a Permit to Work system, a range of regulations impose obligations. Most notably, the Confined Space regulation, as detailed below.

  • Confined Spaces (General Industry). Under 29 CFR 1910.146, a Confined Space Entry Permit is required to authorise employees to enter the space. This sets out the actions to be taken prior to entry. At the conclusion of the entry operation(s), or upon the occurrence of any condition prohibited by the Permit, the Entry Supervisor shall end the entry and cancel the entry permit.
  • Period of retention. The entry permit(s) shall be retained for a period of no less than 1 year for the purpose of reviewing the Confined Space program, including any issues identified and recorded on the permit(s). In an OSHA Letter of Interpretation (LOI) dated 1995-10-06, it is stated that there is no requirement for the entry permit(s) to be maintained at any specific site, so long as they remain readily accessible to the employer and the employer is able to demonstrate that they have met the regulatory requirements.
  • Gas testing. In an OSHA LOI received in Nov 2023, it was confirmed that gas test readings obtained and documented on an entry permit should be maintained for at least 1 year. The general requirement of maintaining exposure records for 30 years does not extend to gas testing, except where testing is mandated by a specific toxic substance standard or 29 CFR 1910.1000. The 1 year is again to facilitate the annual review of the Confined Space program.
  • Construction. A further final rule published by OSHA introduced a new Subpart AA to 29 CFR 1926 regarding Confined Spaces in the Construction sector, coming into effect from 3rd August 2015. Rather than simply imposing a training obligation, a comprehensive Permit to Work scheme was legislated, addressing both hazardous atmospheres and physical dangers.
  • Training. Where an employee is required to undertake training under 29 CFR 1910.146(g)(4), a record shall be maintained listing the employee, the name or initials of the person who provided the training, and date(s) of training. The record shall be made available to the OSHA inspector.

From a software perspective, the system must allow you to store the details of a closed out Permit, any associated issues and the result of the program review, such that the information can be called up at the time of the review. You will wish to confirm with your Compliance Function, or equivalent, the required period of retention for the various types of Permit applicable to your business, given the potential for variation in respect of specific substances. Accordingly, you should not seek to adopt a blanket policy of retaining all Permits for a set time.

Key considerations when evaluating an EPW system

Regardless of whether you elect to license an existing product or develop a bespoke solution, the following features should be considered:

ControlConsiderationRationale
UsersUsers defined by Role; Permit Issuer(s); Delegation capabilityEnsure Permit action can only be undertaken by competent, authorised personnel
SignatureUser-unique login; Secure e-SignatureHSE stipulates that the signature is to ensure Permit is not wrongfully issued or accepted
BlocksGas, Certificate of Isolation, Hazard Assessment and ChecklistsPrevents the missing information issue inherent to paper
TraceabilityRecord of individual(s) undertaking each function and date/timeEnables the sequence of actions and responsible parties to be tracked
AttendanceNo Permit can be issued without site attendance; Issue Printable versionEnsure a copy of the Permit accompanies the workforce on-site
ContinuityContingency to mitigate IT failure or loss of powerPermit system should not be a single point of failure
RetentionPermit type configurable, able to pull historical cancelled permitsAllows OSHA and HSE requirements around retention to be met
ReportingCan report open permits, overlaps and recurring issuesUseful as input into wider monitoring and auditing activities

There are 2 key messages from the HSE that should influence how you assess any solution. As discussed above, you want the issuer of the permit(s) to be able to manage all permits, with appropriate checks and inspections made prior to and on the back of the activity. Equally, the HSE advise that form scrutiny alone will not suffice, and that random checks on site should be added. In addition, the signature requirement should be kept to a minimum, but sufficient to ensure there is an audit trail to support the safety of the activity. Having a series of 10+ signatures each unsigned by an unaware party is no benefit.

Linking permits to site assets and wider IT systems

The main shortfall with many existing e-permit solutions is their lack of connectivity to other relevant data and processes. If a critical piece of plant, service, alarm, electrical supply and so on changes between 08:00 and 10:00, an e-permit issued at 08:00 could be invalid. There are multiple opportunities here for greater integration.

Key areas to consider are:

  1. BMS and wider building services. The BMS will typically give the current status of the building's key services, including electrical distribution, plant and HVAC. If working within the building, you can interrogate this information to help inform the permit, and continue to monitor the status during the duration of the permit. Note that significant development will be required to achieve this, and we offer specialist BMS and Power Management System Integration.
  2. Instrumentation and telemetry. Readings from gas, thermal, spill and personnel detection systems can be fed to the permit interface and remove the need for manual data entry. This will provide greater reliability and an additional data source.
  3. Work orders and maintenance. The majority of e-permits will originate from a work order. By integrating these, you avoid the duplication of data entry and gain visibility of work orders impacted by isolations. We describe our methodology in this blog.
  4. Personnel and access. Being able to determine who is on site, and confirm their level of competency and certification to undertake the permitted activity, will allow the Receiver to substantiate their statement.
  5. Plant and equipment integrity. For example, lifting operations require confirmation of the fitness of the plant. Advances such as live monitoring of wire rope integrity provide tangible data to the Authoriser.
  6. Incident data. Correlating permit data with recorded incidents and near misses can drive further improvements. Our blogs on using data to improve construction safety and IoT on construction sites provide examples.

You will also need to establish the single source of truth for each area, for example isolations, permits and certifications, and avoid multiple fields updating the same data.

Implementing the programme

You should first understand and refine your existing permit process, identifying any gaps that lead to late, amended and unverified permit closures. Once you have defined this, you can then implement your e-permit solution.

A logical progression would be to:

  • Introduce the e-permit for 1 or more high-risk permit categories, such as Confined Space and Hot Work, where known controls can be embedded.
  • Develop a consistent library of tasks, associated isolations and other controls to apply across the estate.
  • Provide user awareness and instruction to Issuers and Receivers, including contingency for system failure.
  • Conduct random spot checks of active works vs. the e-permit display.
  • Return to step 1 at least once per year, referencing closed and cancelled e-permits.

As a minimum, you should measure the number of e-permits raised, placed on Hold and closed late, along with any Hard Stops identified and results from random site checks. An increase in Hard Stops detected will indicate that your e-permit process is effective.

Bespoke e-permit software

While off-the-shelf packages can be suitable for some applications, Data Centre, Industrial and Construction businesses will often have idiosyncratic needs regarding their isolation practices, existing systems and statutory obligations. Here, bespoke software will allow you to develop e-permits aligned to your specific requirements and integrate as needed, for example with BMS, PMS and instrumentation, subject to your desired e-permit retention policy.

At face value, permitting appears to be a simple exercise in digitising a paper-based process. However, as set out above, you must consider the range of external inputs required to enable a robust e-permit process. And critically, the various IT systems that house this data will almost certainly be decoupled from one another.

Our experience in the Data Centre, Built Environment and Construction sectors is that it is possible to harness this data to drive improved e-permits.

Accordingly, we tend to develop our e-permit offering within a broader ecosystem of services, supported by our track record of delivering 250+ solutions to our customer base to a 99.9% availability guarantee, with worldwide coverage. Of course, you don't want your e-permit to become unavailable if your business network goes offline.

LifeSafety.ai demonstrates a path forward for us in AI in construction safety: ongoing data from sites, fed back quickly, while ensuring humans remain decision-makers. This would include the management of work permits.

Harry

Developing work permits to suit your site

Should you require any linkage to other plant, instrumentation or asset management functions, we will be happy to develop this in further discussion. We have significant experience developing large-scale, mission-critical software, including integration to BMS and PMS. If you have a number of processes to automate, look first at our Enterprise Automation Software, before reviewing the broader Product and Services offering.

The LifeSafety.ai case study provides a good example of the use of AI to improve safety across a construction site. Further background information is provided in our post on Construction Safety Technology. You can find out more about implementing permits via our website podtech.com.

FAQ

Will I be able to complete a Permit online?

Provided that your business has implemented ePermits, this is certainly possible. A user will be able to log a Permit via their mobile or desktop device, which will progress to relevant parties to sign off. If working in a Confined Space in the US, the Permit should state the actions taken prior to entry, and be displayed where workers enter. Having a hard-copy printed to leave at the relevant location would be prudent.

What do I mean by 'ePermit'?

An ePermit allows a digital trail to be created of all the steps required to safely carry out a high-risk activity. From logging the Permit through the risk analysis, isolations, sign-offs, transfer and termination of the task, the ePermit will record the user(s) and timestamp of each stage. Sign-off is limited to the activity described in the Permit.

What constitutes an ePermit programme?

A programme will cover the various elements of an organization's Permit to Work practice, including the levels of individuals permitted to grant authorisation, competency requirements, Permit inventory, oversight of the practice and retention of information. These are outlined by the HSE. Similarly, under US Confined Space regulations, the company should undertake a review of all closed-out Permits on a yearly basis.

How far back do I need to retain Permit information?

This will vary according to the different categories of Permit and the legislation in force. As noted above, OSHA requires that Canceled Permits associated with Confined Spaces be retained for a minimum of 12 months for the purpose of the annual audit. The HSE recommends retention on-site for no less than 30 days, followed by longer term storage. Speak to your Health and Safety team regarding the specific retention requirements for your organization.

References

Further reading